The old friend (10+ years, shared history)
For a speech rooted in a long friendship, the goal is to find the story that earns the compliment. Here is an opening, a middle, and a toast that do exactly that.
I've known Marcus for seventeen years. Which means I have been waiting seventeen years to stand up in front of people who love him and tell the truth.
The truth is this: he is one of the best people I have ever known. He is also one of the most infuriating. These two things are not unrelated.
There's a story I've been telling for years, and it goes like this: in 2014, Marcus and I drove from Chicago to Nashville in a car with no AC in August because he'd bought festival tickets from someone on Craigslist and couldn't get his money back. We did not get in. We sat in a Waffle House for two hours, split a coffee, and then drove home. He made a playlist for the drive back. It was only songs about failure.
I laughed for four hours straight. That's who he is. He doesn't get embarrassed by the things that don't work out. He just makes them into a story.
That's also exactly who you want in a marriage.
Jamie, he is a lucky man and he knows it. To Marcus and Jamie, and to all the playlists still ahead.
Why it works: The story earns the compliment. "He is one of the best people I know" is a claim; the Waffle House is the evidence. By the time you say "that's exactly who you want in a marriage," the room believes it.